Walmart sued for Manitowoc Down syndrome firing

MANITOWOC - Wal-Mart Stores East, LP faces a federal lawsuit from the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunities Commission over termination of a 15-year employee of Walmart in Manitowoc with Down syndrome.

According to a news release from EEOC, Manitowoc woman Marlo Spaeth was disciplined for absenteeism after her schedule of 15 years was changed by management. Spaeth typically worked a shift from noon to 4 p.m. most days from Monday to Friday. The new scheduling system called for Spaeth working later and longer shifts and, because of her disability, she was unable to adapt to the changes in routine, the news release said.

Walmart did not change Spaeth’s schedule even after she requested the changes, the news release added. The new schedule took effect in November 2014 and Spaeth was fired for attendance issues July 10, 2015.

RELATED: Orion to defend breach of contract claims

RELATED: Two Rivers Vets Club building closes

Amy Jo Stevenson, Spaeth’s sister and legal guardian, became involved when she received the call from Walmart regarding the termination. Stevenson said she was told the computerized scheduling system could not change Spaeth’s schedule back to what it was originally and was told Spaeth would not be rehired.

“The manager I talked to, she said ‘Well, we have to treat her just like everyone else,’ and I was done talking to her at that point because that is the farthest from the truth,” Stevenson said.

She decided to bring the matter to the EEOC because they had experience dealing with similar cases, she said.

“From the first moment I heard about it (Spaeth’s termination from Walmart), it didn’t feel right,” Stevenson said. “I think it is wrong and I didn’t let it drop. I think they (Walmart) expected me to drop it.”

Stevenson said Spaeth’s Down syndrome makes it extremely difficult to make any changes to her routine.

“We are talking about a person who just can’t easily be taken out of their habits and rituals,” Stevenson said. “It is something that needs to be respected.”

Stevenson said Spaeth was devastated by the termination and still misses working there.

In a statement released by Wal-Mart spokesman Randy Hargrove, he said Spaeth understood her job requirements and understood the importance of working her full work schedule. He said even after being spoken to about her absenteeism, she continually failed to complete her assigned shift.

“We’re sensitive to this situation and we tried to reach an amicable resolution that would support Ms. Spaeth,” Hargrove said. “We remain open to continuing those discussions, but the EEOC has not acted in her best interest.”

The lawsuit filed by EEOC asks the court to order Walmart to reinstate Spaeth with appropriate back pay and compensatory and punitive damages. The lawsuit also seeks a permanent injunction enjoining Walmart from failing to provide a reasonable accommodation for disability and discharging an employee because of a disability.

“Even the nation’s largest private employer must comply with the law’s requirement to make a good-faith effort to accommodate an employee with a disability,” said Julianne Bowman, EEOC district director of the Chicago District, in the news release.

Alisa M. Schafer: 920-686-2105 or aschafer@gannett.com